Peter J Fimbel, 83, of Cape May Court House, formerly of Northvale, NJ passed away peacefully on October 30, 2025. Beloved husband of Kathleen (nee McDonagh). Loving father of Deborah Fowley and husband Ryan. Proud grandfather of Liam and Peter. Dearest brother of Paul Fimbel (late wife Regina) and the late Walter.
A man loved by all who knew him, Peter had a heart as big as his smile. He was always ready to lend a helping hand to anyone in need and never hesitated to go out of his way to make someone’s day brighter. His kindness, generosity, and sense of humor left a lasting mark on everyone he met.
He shared a beautiful 55-year marriage with his devoted wife, Kathleen, whom he deeply adored. Together, they built a life filled with love, laughter, and cherished memories. Peter and Kathleen traveled extensively with dear friends and family, creating countless unforgettable adventures and moments that will be treasured forever.
Peter was a Physical Education teacher for the Closter Board of Education for over 35 years and was actively involved in coaching many different sports. He, along with his good friend and colleague, ran the Closter Summer Recreation program for many years.
Of all his many joys, none compared to the time he spent with his beloved grandsons, who were the light of his life.
Peter was a lifelong fan of the New York Yankees and could often be found cheering them on during every season. He also had a fascination with trains, a hobby that brought him great joy and wonder throughout his life.
He will be remembered for his warmth, compassion, and unwavering love for his family and friends. His spirit will live on in the hearts of all who were fortunate to know him.
Visiting hours are Tuesday, November 4, 2025 from 4 -8PM at Pizzi Funeral Home, 120 Paris Ave, Northvale, NJ. A Funeral Mass will be celebrated on Wednesday, November 5, 2025 at 10 AM at Our Lady of Victories RC Church, Harrington Park, NJ.
In lieu of flowers, donations in Peter’s memory may be made to St. Jude’s Children’s Research Hospital, www.stjude.org.
www.pizzifuneralhome.com
Dear Paul,
I’m so sorry for the loss of your brother.
Sending prayers for comfort and strength.
I’m very sorry to hear of Mr. Fimble’s passing. He was a great teacher to have in both Tenakill and Villiage School. I also was fortunate to work with, and learn from him, in the Closter Rec program at the beginning of my teaching career. My condolences to the Fimble family.
My husband said it best. Pete was the guy every father prayed his daughter would marry.
He was so loved and will be so missed. Heaven just gained another angel.
Had the pleasure of knowing Pete since moving in our neighborhood Pete knew everyone in the neighborhood and he was the watchdog for sure always taking your garbage can up from the street even though you were capable he always wanted to do it . I got to know him a little bit the last couple years truly a nice man and his lovely wife as well. God bless him. I will pray for the family rest in peace, my friend,
Dan Cappelletti. ( friend)
You couldn’t have grown up in Closter in the ’60s, ’70s, or ’80s maybe even beyond without knowing Mr. Fimble. He was truly a fixture in the community. I remember it being a big deal when he was the gym teacher at Tenakill and married one of the teachers, obviously his wife. May his soul rest in peace.
He brought peace and joy to many and taught countless important lessons. I still remember talking with him in the hall when I was a young child at Tenakill Elementary. He will be fondly remembered by all who knew him.
Blessings and peace to all in Jesus’ name.
There’s only one Pete! Only by sheer and divine luck, caddying , first meet up, ! $2.50 a bag! And then college! Did not know we would choose the same school? I,remember! It was as the cheapest! And teaching!
Where Pete excelled “Mr.Fixit” even a broken heart! Pete could you take a look as favor ?
Slock
Pete was definitely a gem. I will always remember him for his kindness, sense of humor and his ability to make you feel special. I’m keeping Kathleen, Deborah, Ryan, Pete’s grandsons and his brother Paul in my prayers.
Mr. Fimbel was one of a kind. Teaching middle schoolers is difficult, I’ve done it. In addition to being a fabulous instructor, he was truly just a sweet man. I am blessed to have known him.
I’ll light a candle for you, Mr Fimbel, on Sunday.
Peace